Eyeliner swatch and pen

10 Best Eyeliners (2026): Liquid, Gel and Pencil Picks for Every Eye Shape

A good eyeliner can change the whole look of your eyes in a minute. The right formula and shape make your eyes look bigger, brighter or more dramatic, while a bad liner smudges, flakes or irritates. Because liner sits close to the lashes and sometimes on the waterline, safety and removal matter as much as color.

Part of our guide to makeup how-to. Start with: How to Choose the Right Eye Makeup Color for Your Eyes and Skin

Eyeliner pen, pencil and gel pot

This guide compares 10 eyeliners, from precise liquid pens and a classic gel pot to pencils. They differ in how easy they are to control, how long they last and how hard they are to remove. The best eyeliner is the one that suits your eye shape, your skill level and your comfort.

Top 10 at a glance

#ProductBest ForStandout Feature
1Stila Stay All Day Dual-Ended Liquid Eye LinerStila Stay All Day Dual-Ended Liquid Eye LinerTwo line widths in one penA dual-ended pen for thin and thick linesBuy Now
2Estee Lauder Little Black Liner Waterproof Liquid EyelinerEstee Lauder Little Black Liner Waterproof Liquid EyelinerA waterproof liquid with variable linesThick, thin and ultra-fine lines from one penBuy Now
3M.A.C. Fluidline Eye Liner Gel (Blacktrack)M.A.C. Fluidline Eye Liner Gel (Blacktrack)A precise, creamy gel lineA pro-favorite gel potBuy Now
4Anastasia Beverly Hills Darkside Waterproof Gel Eyeliner PencilAnastasia Beverly Hills Darkside Waterproof Gel Eyeliner PencilSmudgy or sharp lines with one pencilA creamy waterproof gel pencilBuy Now
5CLIO Extreme Gelpresso Pencil EyelinerCLIO Extreme Gelpresso Pencil EyelinerWaterproof, high-pigment pencilA high-pigment Korean gel pencilBuy Now
6Revlon ColorStay Pencil Waterproof Eyeliner (2-Pack)Revlon ColorStay Pencil Waterproof Eyeliner (2-Pack)A classic pencil for everyday wearA waterproof pencil in a 2-packBuy Now
7Milani The Tank Liquid EyelinerMilani The Tank Liquid EyelinerLong wear at a low priceA smudge-proof liquid linerBuy Now
8NYX Professional Makeup Epic Ink EyelinerNYX Professional Makeup Epic Ink EyelinerA fine, flexible brush tipA popular liquid pen with 24-hour wear claimsBuy Now
9L’Oreal Paris Haute Precision Waterproof Liquid EyelinerL’Oreal Paris Haute Precision Waterproof Liquid EyelinerSmudge-proof detail workA precision pen with a micro tipBuy Now
10Maybelline Hyper Easy Liquid Pen No-Skip EyelinerMaybelline Hyper Easy Liquid Pen No-Skip EyelinerA beginner-friendly easy penA satin-finish pen made for beginnersBuy Now

We chose products with strong ratings from many shoppers and list them from highest list price to lowest. Listings show one shade, usually black. Everything here is research-based, not lab tested.

Free 30-day trial

Black Friday is coming: shop the deals with Prime

Fast, free delivery on millions of eligible items
Prime members get early access to select Black Friday and Cyber Monday deals
Prime Video, Music and more included
Start my free Prime trial →
New members only. Cancel any time before the trial ends to avoid being charged.
Affiliate link: we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you.

Liner shade and finish matter too. A deep black gives the strongest contrast, while brown or charcoal looks softer on fair skin and in daytime looks. Fine tips are better for thin lines, and felt or brush tips suit wings. Think about how much time you have each morning before you decide.

Eye health matters more than a perfect wing. Replace liners about every three months, never share them and stop using any product that makes your eyes red, sore or swollen. For removal, our guides to cleansing balms and micellar waters will help.

Each card below explains who the liner suits, what it does well and where it falls short, so you can pick the right one for your routine.

As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. This does not change which products we include.

Best Premium LiquidStila Stay All Day Dual-Ended Liquid Eye Liner
Stila Stay All Day Dual-Ended Liquid Eye Liner
Check Price on Amazon
Best Waterproof LuxuryEstee Lauder Little Black Liner Waterproof Liquid Eyeliner
Estee Lauder Little Black Liner Waterproof Liquid Eyeliner
Check Price on Amazon
Best OverallM.A.C. Fluidline Eye Liner Gel (Blacktrack)
M.A.C. Fluidline Eye Liner Gel (Blacktrack)
Check Price on Amazon

In Brief

  • M.A.C. Fluidline is our top pick, with the best rating on the list.
  • NYX Epic Ink and Maybelline Hyper Easy are the best pens for beginners.
  • Revlon ColorStay is the classic pencil for everyday wear.
  • Waterproof liners need an oil-based remover.
  • Replace eyeliner every three months and never share it.
  • Only use liners labeled safe for the waterline on the waterline.

The 10 Best Eyeliners Right Now

These 10 picks run from the highest list price to the lowest and include liquid pens, gel pencils, a gel pot and a classic pencil. We kept eyeliners rated 4.3 stars or better with at least 400 ratings. Each Amazon listing shows one shade, usually black.

Nothing here is lab tested; the notes come from each listing and from general eye-safety guidance.

1
Best Premium Liquid

Stila Stay All Day Dual-Ended Liquid Eye Liner

Stila Stay All Day Dual-Ended Liquid Eye Liner

Best for: Two line widths in one pen

Stila’s Stay All Day is a dual-ended liquid liner with a fine tip on one end and a thicker tip on the other. It has a 4.4-star rating from nearly 790 ratings.

It is the most expensive pick, but two tips let you switch between a thin daytime line and a bolder winged look. It takes practice to handle liquid liners precisely.

  • Dual-ended liquid eyeliner
  • Fine and thick tips
  • Long-wear formula
  • Rating of 4.4 from nearly 790 ratings

Pros

  • Two line widths
  • Many ratings
  • Precise application

Cons

  • Highest price
  • Liquid liner needs a steady hand

Skip it if: you prefer a pencil for easy control.

Check Price on Amazon
2
Best Waterproof Luxury

Estee Lauder Little Black Liner Waterproof Liquid Eyeliner

Estee Lauder Little Black Liner Waterproof Liquid Eyeliner

Best for: A waterproof liquid with variable lines

Estee Lauder’s Little Black Liner is a waterproof liquid liner that can make thick, thin or ultra-fine lines. It has a 4.5-star rating from nearly 600 ratings.

It is a luxury option that suits people who want a precise, long-lasting black line. Waterproof formulas need an oil-based remover.

  • Waterproof liquid eyeliner
  • Thick, thin and ultra-fine lines
  • Long-wear formula
  • Rating of 4.5 from nearly 600 ratings

Pros

  • Waterproof
  • Versatile line widths
  • High rating

Cons

  • Premium price
  • Harder to remove

Skip it if: you have sensitive eyes or remove makeup with water only.

Check Price on Amazon
3
Best Overall

M.A.C. Fluidline Eye Liner Gel (Blacktrack)

M.A.C. Fluidline Eye Liner Gel (Blacktrack)

Best for: A precise, creamy gel line

M.A.C. Fluidline is a classic gel liner in a pot, loved by makeup artists for its creamy, long-wearing black. It has a 4.6-star rating from over 840 ratings, the best score on the list.

It requires a thin angled brush, so it is less convenient than a pen. In return, you get a smooth, precise line that can be softened or sharpened.

  • Gel eyeliner in a pot
  • Blacktrack shade
  • Used with a brush
  • Rating of 4.6 from over 840 ratings

Pros

  • Top rating
  • Precise, creamy line
  • Professional favorite

Cons

  • Needs a brush
  • Gel can dry out if left open

Skip it if: you want a quick, no-brush option.

Check Price on Amazon
4
Best Gel Pencil

Anastasia Beverly Hills Darkside Waterproof Gel Eyeliner Pencil

Anastasia Beverly Hills Darkside Waterproof Gel Eyeliner Pencil

Best for: Smudgy or sharp lines with one pencil

Anastasia Beverly Hills offers a waterproof gel pencil that glides on smoothly and can be smudged or kept sharp. It has a 4.4-star rating from over 700 ratings.

It suits people who like a smoky edge and a creamy texture. Pencils need sharpening, and gel pencils soften in hot weather.

  • Waterproof gel eyeliner pencil
  • Creamy texture
  • Smudge or define
  • Rating of 4.4 from over 700 ratings

Pros

  • Waterproof
  • Smoky or sharp lines
  • Many ratings

Cons

  • Needs sharpening
  • Can soften in heat

Skip it if: you prefer a precision liquid pen.

Check Price on Amazon
5
Best Korean Gel Pencil

CLIO Extreme Gelpresso Pencil Eyeliner

CLIO Extreme Gelpresso Pencil Eyeliner

Best for: Waterproof, high-pigment pencil

CLIO’s Gelpresso is a waterproof, high-pigment gel pencil from a leading Korean brand. It has a 4.4-star rating from over 770 ratings.

It is a good alternative if you like a pencil with strong color. Like most gel pencils, it can smudge on oily eyelids without a primer.

  • Gel pencil eyeliner
  • Waterproof formula
  • High pigment
  • Rating of 4.4 from over 770 ratings

Pros

  • Strong color
  • Waterproof
  • Mid-range price

Cons

  • Can smudge on oily lids
  • Less widely sold

Skip it if: you have oily eyelids and no primer.

Check Price on Amazon
6
Best Classic Pencil

Revlon ColorStay Pencil Waterproof Eyeliner (2-Pack)

Revlon ColorStay Pencil Waterproof Eyeliner (2-Pack)

Best for: A classic pencil for everyday wear

Revlon ColorStay is a classic waterproof pencil, sold here as a 2-pack in black. It has a 4.5-star rating from over 550 ratings.

It is a simple, familiar option for beginners. It is not as dramatic as liquid liners but easy to smudge and control.

  • Waterproof pencil eyeliner
  • Black shade
  • 2-pack
  • Rating of 4.5 from over 550 ratings

Pros

  • Beginner friendly
  • 2-pack value
  • Good rating

Cons

  • Less dramatic
  • Needs sharpening

Skip it if: you want a bold graphic line.

Check Price on Amazon
7
Best Drugstore Liquid

Milani The Tank Liquid Eyeliner

Milani The Tank Liquid Eyeliner

Best for: Long wear at a low price

Milani’s The Tank is a no-skip, waterproof and smudge-proof liquid eyeliner. It has a 4.3-star rating from over 870 ratings.

It is a good drugstore liquid for daily wear. The 4.3-star rating is the lowest on the list.

  • No-skip liquid eyeliner
  • Waterproof and smudge-proof
  • Black shade
  • Rating of 4.3 from over 870 ratings

Pros

  • Many ratings
  • Low price
  • Long wear

Cons

  • Lowest rating
  • Hard to remove

Skip it if: you need an easy-to-remove formula.

Check Price on Amazon
8
Best Pen Value

NYX Professional Makeup Epic Ink Eyeliner

NYX Professional Makeup Epic Ink Eyeliner

Best for: A fine, flexible brush tip

NYX’s Epic Ink is a waterproof liquid pen with a flexible brush tip and a claim of up to 24 hours of wear. It has a 4.5-star rating from over 1,080 ratings, the most on the list.

It is excellent for beginners learning wings. Wear claims are the brand’s, and few eyeliners last a full day without touch-ups.

  • Waterproof liquid eyeliner
  • Flexible brush tip
  • Up to 24-hour wear claim
  • Rating of 4.5 from over 1,080 ratings

Pros

  • Most ratings
  • Easy to control
  • Low price

Cons

  • Wear claim is optimistic
  • Can be hard to remove

Skip it if: you want a gel pencil texture.

Check Price on Amazon
9
Best Precise Drugstore Pen

L’Oreal Paris Haute Precision Waterproof Liquid Eyeliner

L'Oreal Paris Haute Precision Waterproof Liquid Eyeliner

Best for: Smudge-proof detail work

L’Oreal’s Haute Precision is a waterproof, smudge-proof liquid liner with a micro tip for fine detail. It has a 4.4-star rating from over 810 ratings.

It suits people who want thin, accurate lines. Like most waterproof liners, it needs a gentle oil-based remover.

  • Waterproof liquid eyeliner
  • Micro tip
  • Smudge-proof
  • Rating of 4.4 from over 810 ratings

Pros

  • Precise
  • Many ratings
  • Low price

Cons

  • Hard to remove
  • Thin line only

Skip it if: you want a thick wing in one stroke.

Check Price on Amazon
10
Best Budget Pen

Maybelline Hyper Easy Liquid Pen No-Skip Eyeliner

Maybelline Hyper Easy Liquid Pen No-Skip Eyeliner

Best for: A beginner-friendly easy pen

Maybelline’s Hyper Easy Liquid Pen has a no-skip tip and a satin finish in a waterproof formula. It has a 4.3-star rating from nearly 680 ratings.

It is the cheapest pick, ideal for practicing. The rating is the lowest on the list, tied with Milani.

  • No-skip liquid pen
  • Satin finish
  • Waterproof formula
  • Rating of 4.3 from nearly 680 ratings

Pros

  • Lowest price
  • Beginner friendly
  • Many ratings

Cons

  • Rating is 4.3
  • Waterproof formula is harder to remove

Skip it if: you want a premium finish.

Check Price on Amazon

How We Chose These Eyeliners

We searched Amazon for liquid, gel and pencil eyeliners and kept those rated 4.3 stars or better with at least 400 ratings. We removed sponsored placements and duplicate listings, limited each brand to two picks and ordered the list by price.

We checked claims such as waterproof and 24-hour wear against listing text and treated them as the brand’s claims. We did not test the products.

These are research-based picks, not lab tests. Prices and ratings change.

RuleWhat we applied
Rating floor4.3 stars or better
Review floor400 or more ratings
Brand limitTwo per brand
OrderHighest list price first
MixLiquid, gel and pencil
Eyeliner types compared: liquid, gel and pencil

Liquid, Gel and Pencil: Which Type Is for You

Liquid liner gives the sharpest, most dramatic line, and it dries to a long-wearing finish. Gel liner is creamy and flexible, and works with a brush for precise lines. Pencil is the easiest to control and the best for smudging and waterlines.

TypeBest forWatch out for
Liquid penWings and graphic linesNeeds a steady hand
Gel potPro-level precisionNeeds a brush
Gel pencilSmoky and sharp linesNeeds sharpening
Classic pencilBeginners, waterlineLess dramatic

If you are new to eyeliner, start with a pencil or a felt-tip liquid pen.

Matching Eyeliner to Your Eye Shape

Hooded eyes usually look best with a thinner line drawn with eyes open. Round eyes can be elongated with a wing that extends outward. Almond eyes suit most styles. Close-set eyes benefit from a line that starts at the center of the eye and extends outward. Downturned eyes look lifted with a small upward wing.

Draw the wing with your eyes open and looking straight ahead, so you can see exactly where the line will sit.

How to Choose the Right One

Think about your skill level, how you remove makeup and whether your eyes are sensitive. Waterproof formulas last through tears and humidity but need more effort to remove. If your eyes water or you wear contacts, choose a pencil that does not flake.

Check the label for the waterline. Not all liners are safe for the waterline, and using the wrong one can irritate the eyes.

Helps

  • Match the type to your skill
  • Check that it is safe for the waterline
  • Replace every three months

Backfires

  • Do not share eyeliner
  • Do not use liquid liner after an eye infection
  • Do not tugging lid skin

How to Apply Eyeliner for a Clean Line

Start with a clean, dry eyelid. A thin layer of eyeshadow primer or powder can help liner last on oily lids. Rest your elbow on a table to steady your hand.

  1. Prep the lid

    Apply a thin layer of primer or powder if your lids are oily.

  2. Steady your hand

    Rest your elbow on a table and look down into a mirror.

  3. Draw small strokes

    Make short dashes along the lash line and connect them.

  4. Add the wing

    Draw the wing outward and upward, following the lower lash line.

  5. Let it dry

    Wait a moment before blinking to avoid transfer.

Stop using any eye product that causes burning, redness or swelling, and see a doctor if symptoms continue.

Eye Safety and Replacement

Eyeliner can carry bacteria once opened. Replace liquid liners about every three months and pencils every six months, or sooner after an eye infection. Never share liners.

Sharpen pencils regularly to remove the outer layer. Avoid lining the inner waterline if you have dry eyes or wear contacts, because it can clog the oil glands.

HabitWhy it matters
Replace liquid liner every 3 monthsBacteria can grow
Sharpen pencilsRemoves the contaminated surface
Avoid waterline with contactsCan irritate and clog glands
Do not shareSpreads germs

Removing Eyeliner Gently

Hold a pad soaked in remover on the closed eye for several seconds, then wipe downward without rubbing. Waterproof liners dissolve best with oil-based removers or balms. Rubbing can break lashes and irritate the delicate skin.

Rinse off residue with water and follow with your usual cleanser.

Honest Limits

No eyeliner stays perfect all day on oily lids or watery eyes. Waterproof does not mean tear-proof, and 24-hour wear claims are best treated as marketing. A primer and a light powder help.

Shades also look different on different skin tones, and black can look harsh on fair skin. Brown or charcoal can be softer.

When to See a Professional

See an eye doctor if you notice redness, sore eyelids, discharge, vision changes or a gritty feeling after using eyeliner. Lash loss or crusting should also be checked.

This article is educational and not medical advice. The author is a registered pharmacist, not a dermatologist or eye doctor, and cannot diagnose conditions.

Frequently Asked Questions

Which eyeliner is best for beginners?

Pencils and felt-tip pens like NYX Epic Ink and Maybelline Hyper Easy are easiest to control.

Is liquid liner harder to use?

Yes, it needs a steady hand, but practice helps.

Can I use eyeliner on my waterline?

Only if the label says it is safe for the waterline.

How often should I replace eyeliner?

About every three months for liquid and every six months for pencils.

Why does my eyeliner smudge?

Oily lids and tears are common causes. Use a primer and a light powder.

How do I remove waterproof eyeliner?

Use an oil-based remover or balm and hold it on the eye before wiping.

Is gel eyeliner better than pencil?

Gel is creamier and more precise, but it needs a brush.

Which color is best?

Black is dramatic, while brown or charcoal is softer.

Can I wear eyeliner with contacts?

Yes, but avoid the waterline and flaking formulas.

Is the most expensive eyeliner better?

Not necessarily. NYX and Maybelline have excellent ratings.

Where This Leaves You

The best eyeliner matches your skill, your eye shape and your comfort. Practice with a pencil or felt-tip pen, replace products on time and remove them gently.

M.A.C. Fluidline leads our list for precision, with NYX, Maybelline and Revlon the best value picks.

Our top pick: Stila Stay All Day Dual-Ended Liquid Eye Liner

M.A.C. Fluidline takes first place for its 4.6-star rating and precise gel finish, though it needs a brush. If you want a pen for easy daily lines, NYX Epic Ink and Maybelline Hyper Easy are strong, low-priced picks, and Revlon ColorStay is the pencil classic.

Check Price on Amazon
Rakib Sarwar

Written by

Rakib Sarwar

Registered pharmacist and founder of Facial Adviser. Rakib's pharmacy training covers how skincare actives work and interact; a later course in cosmetology turned that into a focus on facial treatments and skincare products. He plans, researches and edits every guide on the site and checks health claims against sources such as the American Academy of Dermatology, the FDA and the NIH. He is not a dermatologist; see the Editorial Policy and Medical Disclaimer.

About · Editorial policy · How we choose products · Medical disclaimer · Contact

Free 30-day trial

Turn skincare time into me-time with a free audiobook

Thousands of wellness, self-care and beauty titles
Listen while you cleanse, mask or get ready
Keep your first pick even if you cancel
Try Audible free →
New Audible members only; terms apply. Cancel any time before the trial ends.
Affiliate link: we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you.

Similar Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *